Comparison of the therapeutic effects of total laryngectomy and a larynx-preservation approach in patients with T4a laryngeal cancer and thyroid cartilage invasion: A multicenter retrospective review

Abstract

Background. In T4a laryngeal cancer with thyroid cartilage invasion, no optimal frontline treatment has yet been defined in con- trolled trials. Methods. We reviewed data from 89 patients with T4a laryngeal cancer featuring thyroid cartilage invasion who were treated initially with either total laryngectomy (n 5 53) or a larynx-preservation strategy (n 5 36). Results. The median progression-free survival (PFS) of the total laryn- gectomy group had not been attained at the time of analysis and was thus significantly longer than that of the larynx-preservation group (8.7 months). The median overall survival (OS) of patients who underwent total laryngectomy was 87.2 months, significantly longer than that of the larynx-preservation group (31.3 months). The survival benefit of primary surgery compared to a larynx-preservation strategy was more striking in patients of lower N classifications. Conclusion. Total laryngectomy may be a better therapeutic option to treat T4a laryngeal cancer featuring thyroid cartilage invasion, especially in patients exhibiting limited nodal involvement (N0/N1).